Brazil's Supreme Federal Court (STF) decano Gilmar Mendes said Friday that lifting secrecy on Federal Police reports linking four sitting justices to the collapsed Banco Master does not resolve the controversy. Speaking at a legal forum in Buenos Aires, Mendes argued the full court should debate the matter rather than leave it with a smaller panel.
The statement came hours after STF President Edson Fachin authorized disclosure of the report on Justice André Mendonça at Mendonça's own request. Fachin has forwarded four police reports — covering Mendonça, Alexandre de Moraes, Dias Toffoli, and Kassio Nunes Marques — to Prosecutor-General Paulo Gonet for review.
What the reports allege
The Federal Police found no direct messages between Mendonça and former Master controller Daniel Vorcaro. The report cites 11 third-party references to Mendonça but notes the search was not exhaustive. Mendonça met Vorcaro once in March 2025 regarding a sugar-industry precatory case and voted against Vorcaro's interest.
The case against Moraes is more substantial. PF investigators identified at least six meetings between Moraes and Vorcaro between February 2024 and April 2025. Messages from Vorcaro's phone show the banker seeking Moraes's help to stall investigations and advance a sale of Master to state-owned bank BRB. Two days before his November 2025 arrest, Vorcaro asked Moraes whether he should flee the country.
A contract worth approximately R$ 131 million (roughly USD 24 million at recent rates) between Master and the law firm of Moraes's wife, Viviane Barci de Moraes, adds weight to the inquiry. PF metadata indicates Moraes edited a draft of that contract before signing. The firm says the engagement was regular and legally unobstructed.
Toffoli and Nunes Marques
Justice Dias Toffoli's family company, Maridt Participações, held a stake in the Tayayá resort in Paraná until February 2025. The stake was sold in 2021 to a fund linked to Vorcaro's brother-in-law, Fabiano Zettel, and later liquidated to another holding company. Toffoli denies receiving any payments from Vorcaro and says he was not the company's administrator.
Regarding Nunes Marques, a July 2025 message from Master's former legal director to Vorcaro asked whether a monthly payment of R$ 500,000 (roughly USD 90,000) to Nunes Marques's son Kevin should continue. Nunes Marques denies his son ever provided services to or received compensation from the bank, and says no messages exist between himself and Vorcaro.
Procedural backdrop
Toffoli led the Master investigation until February 2026, when he stepped aside after the resort dealings surfaced. Mendonça then assumed the rapporteurship. In September, after the police reports became public, Fachin centralized the matter in the court's presidency. Gilmar Mendes had previously urged a new random draw for the rapporteur — a move analysts say could prevent Mendonça from regaining control.
Mendes characterized the court's September 15 session, which devolved into public accusations among justices, as "unfortunate" and "fateful." He reiterated Friday that the full bench should decide how to proceed.


