Brazil's National Electric Energy Agency (Aneel) has formed a majority among its directors in favor of recommending the termination of Enel Distribuição São Paulo's concession contract, citing repeated failures in service delivery across Greater São Paulo. The recommendation now moves to the Ministry of Mines and Energy (MME), which holds final authority over the concession.
Director Gentil Nogueira, who had placed the case under review since October 6, resumed his analysis on Tuesday and joined relatora Agnes Costa in voting for contract revocation. Interim director Ludimila Lima and director Willamy Frota had already voted with Costa, creating a four-director majority. Director-general Sandoval Feitosa requested a further adjournment before casting his vote, delaying formal conclusion of the proceeding.
Pattern of prolonged outages
The regulatory action follows a series of major blackouts that left millions without power. In November 2023, a severe storm cut electricity to more than 2 million customers. An October 2024 storm affected roughly 3.1 million, with some areas waiting days for restoration. The most recent large-scale event, an extratropical cyclone in December 2025, left over 2 million consumers without service, again for multiple days.
Aneel argues the problem is not the weather itself but the utility's capacity to mobilize crews, manage emergencies, and restore supply quickly. The agency says previous corrective measures have proven insufficient.
Disputed performance claims
During his vote, Nogueira contested Enel's assertion that it had adequately responded to extreme weather. He noted the company's favorable metrics covered events affecting at most 17% of its customer base. In the single extreme event of the period — the December 2025 cyclone that hit 52% of customers — only 80.2% of connections were restored within 24 hours.
Enel São Paulo maintains it complies with its concession contract and the recovery plan presented to Aneel. The company says it has shown the best performance improvement in the sector for indicators such as average emergency response time and prolonged interruptions. It characterized the latest adjournment as another opportunity for its technical arguments to be evaluated.
Political and institutional dimensions
Nogueira proposed creating a joint working group with the MME to manage the consequences of a potential contract termination, noting the case now involves multiple oversight bodies — including the Comptroller General (CGU), the Attorney General's Office (AGU), and the Federal Audit Court (TCU). "This issue has extrapolated the agency's limits and today has an institutional dimension," he said.
Sandoval Feitosa defended Aneel's supervisory record, stating that no report had identified regulatory failures in its oversight of Enel SP.
Next steps and market interest
Even if Aneel formalizes the revocation recommendation, the concession does not end automatically. The MME must execute the decision, weighing continuity of supply, indemnification for unamortized investments, and the model for a successor operator. The current concession runs until 2028.
Minister Alexandre Silveira has said the federal government will comply with whatever Aneel decides. The TCU previously urged the government and Aneel to assess alternatives, including identifying capable operators, indemnification costs, and tariff impacts.
Private-sector interest is already visible. CPFL has publicly stated it would consider bidding for the asset if it comes to market. Analysts also name Neoenergia, Equatorial, and Âmbar as potential buyers. Any transfer would need to address valuation, investment recovery, and service continuity for São Paulo's 7.5 million consumers.

